The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” icon

The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems”




Скачати 61.67 Kb.
НазваThe Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems”
Дата29.06.2012
Розмір61.67 Kb.
ТипДокументи

The Review of the Scientific Article to

E-Journal “Development of Economic Systems”


Dear Reviewer,

You can help the author, if you fill this review and suggest some improvements to his material. You can help the editor by commenting on the technical significance and accuracy of the work. Your comments will be taken into consideration when the final decision about the publication of materials.

All your comments will be forwarded to the author while you remain anonymous.

Please pay special attention on conformity of materials to a profile of the journal and correctness of references to publications, which posted the results of studies on the subject of articles.


Paper Title:




Date of the Review





Just mark by «х» fields proper to your opinion.


  1. Is the topic appropriate for publication in these transactions?







Yes







Perhaps







No




  1. Is the material written by the scientific language?







Yes







No




  1. Is the coverage of the topic sufficiently comprehensive and balanced?







Yes










Important information is missing or superficially treated










Content is unbalanced somewhere, but not seriously










Some parts are paid too much attention




  1. How would you describe the scientific specifics of the paper?







Surface










Suitable for the non-specialist










Appropriate for the generally knowledgeable individual working in the field










Suitable only for an expert




  1. How would you rate the proposed structure of the material as a whole?







Excellent







Good







Fair







Poor




  1. Do you think that the abstract of the material is written correctly and clearly?







Yes







No




  1. Are symbols, terms, and concepts defined clearly?







Yes







Not always







No




  1. Your assessment of conformity of the material to requirements of the journal:







Excellent







Good







Fair







Poor




  1. How would you rate the scientific contents of the paper?







Excellent







Good







Fair







Poor




  1. How would you rate the novelty of the paper?







Completely new







Fairly new







Some new







Not new




  1. How would you rate the spelling and grammatical style of the material?







Completely correct







Mostly correct







Partially correct







invalid




  1. If it is necessary, you may attach additional sheets with comments and make notes on the manuscript. _________________________________________________________________

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


  1. Recommendation.







Publish as is










Publish with minor modifications (as noted in Section 12)










Review again after major changes (as noted in Section 12)










Refuse (A major rewrite is required. Author should be encouraged to resubmit rewritten paper)










Refuse (Paper is seriously flawed; do not encourage resubmission)




  1. Do you consider this paper a candidate for an award for outstanding quality?







Yes







No




Reviewer’s name:




Reviewer’s contact information:




E-mail address:




Phone number:




Reviewer’s signature:





! The author’s right to unpublished manuscripts !

The author retains the right to the unpublished work. A reviewer should not use the results or ideas obtained through the review process in his/her research.


^ Please send this completed form (and possibly a copy of the manuscript) to

Editorial Board of the journal “Development of Economic Systems”,

Department of Economic Theory, Sumy State University,

Rymskiy-Korsakov Street, 2,

40007 Sumy, Ukraine

or by e-mail:

development-es@ya.ru


^ 12. COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE ARTICLE
























































































































































Схожі:

The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” iconДокументи
1. /Review of the scientific article.doc
The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” iconVisnyk of Economical Science of the Donbas Region 2013, №2 (32) Contents scientific articles
М., Kaluzhna O. O. Impact of Foreign Direct Investments on Economic and Social Development of Luhansk Region
The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” iconBanks and Bank Systems International Research Journal

The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” iconInstrustions of manuscript origin design for publication in the journal “electromechanical and energy saving up systems”

The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” iconInstrustions for paper origin design for publication in the journal “electromechanical and energy saving up systems”

The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” iconImportance dataware for social-economic systems rudenko Y. G., gr. E-72

The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” iconThe Systems Development Life Cycle

The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” iconRecommendations for writing authors summary (abstract) of scientific articles in the journal

The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” iconRecommendations for writing authors summary (abstract) of scientific articles in the journal

The Review of the Scientific Article to e-journal “Development of Economic Systems” iconEuroasian perspectives of the banking systems development

Додайте кнопку на своєму сайті:
Документи


База даних захищена авторським правом ©zavantag.com 2000-2013
При копіюванні матеріалу обов'язкове зазначення активного посилання відкритою для індексації.
звернутися до адміністрації
Документи